Question of the day

spkennyuk

Member
Messages
5,959
How do you change a gas to a liquid without going through a phase change?
Why could this be useful?

Im no chemist but isnt there something about the tripple state of water being a gas a liquid and a solid at the same time so i assume no phase change has taken place if its all three at once.
 

Caldy999

Junior Member
Messages
445
I presume that cooling is involved I.e. condensation, but why is this useful? Air conditioning?
 
Last edited:

GeoffCapes

Member
Messages
14,000
Is this something to do with hydrocarbons? Isn't there a process where natural gas is partially oxidised which removes carbon monoxide, (the added benefit) and can then be transported in a liquid form?

I may have just made that lot up, but I seem to remember a company I looked at in my share dealing days did something like that.
 

MrPea

Member
Messages
3,015
There's a lot of thinking along the right lines. A couple of clues:
- The mostly commonly used chemical for this is carbon dioxide
- The temperature and pressure of the "triple point" of a chemical as far too cold and decompressed for this super-state.

I'll check in at lunch time to see if another clue is required. Navcorr, you may need to answer this later.
 

CatmanV2

Member
Messages
48,782
If memory serves, CO2 at STP sublimates. If you let it transition from a solid in a sealed (strong enough) vessel, you get liquid CO2

I assume therefore that if you apply pressure to gaseous CO2, you'd end up with a liquid but it still seems to me to be going through a phase change.

Best guess for use would be refrigeration.


C
 

zagatoes30

Member
Messages
20,940
If memory serves, CO2 at STP sublimates. If you let it transition from a solid in a sealed (strong enough) vessel, you get liquid CO2

I assume therefore that if you apply pressure to gaseous CO2, you'd end up with a liquid but it still seems to me to be going through a phase change.

Best guess for use would be refrigeration.


C
WHS again, this was my thought process but there is still a phase change is there not?
 

Navcorr

Member
Messages
3,839
Happy to answer but if others would prefer to wait for another clue??
Plus the rugby is starting soon.
 

MrPea

Member
Messages
3,015
Yes, the rugby is on indeed.
Next clue:
CO2 will start to act rather interestingly around its critical point... ~31 degrees and 1000 psi.
 

Navcorr

Member
Messages
3,839
Navcorr, you may need to answer this later.

If I may step in as it"s unlikely to be "guessed". MrPea is referring to supercritical fluids (SCF) and their use.

An SCF is a chemical compound held above it's critical point by temperature and pressure. When a compound is SC it is neither a gas nor a liquid. It behaves as both. Can you argue that the change from liquid or gas to SCF is a change of state? Perhaps but strictly it isn't. Think of it as an alternate state rather than a change of state.

Typically, CO2 is used as it is cheap, inert and relatively safe. Water too. In recent years many "green" applications have been developed which will obviously be of interest to V6 & V8 petrol heads. ;) Joking aside, for example, where volatile organic solvents can be replaced with an appropriate SCF. Dry cleaning being an everyday use.

As MrPea said previously there's been some good thinking. This isn't typical everyday chemistry though. However, SCF's are widely used in polymer chemistry which I just happened to study at Uni.

As such, given the unfair advantage, maybe someone else should nominate themselves the next QM. Perhaps CatmanV2 as SCF's are being used for refrigeration - just not in the manner stated.
 

Andyk

Member
Messages
61,154
There has been a number of series of the 2 dollar note. First one ended in 1966. In 1976 the series two was printed and this was only really issued for a year but in that time the series three came out. People believe that the note has been discontinued but is still available although finding one is pretty hard.