Ghibli S or 2009-2012 Quattroporte Sport GT S ???

Bourekoue

Junior Member
Messages
297
You are, of course, quite right Bourekoue. There's no doubting that the later 4.7 QP GTS is technically better than the earlier 4.2 QP GTS, it's just that I prefer the original styling of the earlier car. Just as in the same way I like the early LP400 Countach over the later Anniversary Countach (as an example).

The Rapide is a lovely thing, but not as practical or reliable as the QP. The running costs of a V12 Aston are higher than those of a V8 Maserati also. Nice though. And the deprecation on the early cars seems to be levelling out now. A friend of mine bought a very nice one earlier this summer for about £80k which seemed very good value. He traded in his old DB9 for it, and instantly reported just how much more modern and advanced (and plain better) the Rapide was to drive. Certainly worth a close inspection and test drive.

Thanks Ewan.
I respect your opinion and although I disagree with you on the QP I definitely agree with you regarding the Lamborghini.
The rapide also seems good value to me with cars now starting at about 60k.
 

npaskin

New Member
Messages
506
....I need a practical 4 door saloon ...
Anybody have any thoughts on the rapide in relation to QP GT S ?
The QP is a 4 door practical 4 seater; the Rapide is a 2+2. I was very surprised by the back seats of the Rapide when I tried it - very claustrophobic, tiny windows, no room at all either side, no decent leg room. I had great difficulty getting in and out the back easily (and I'm only average height); if you or your family are tall you'd really not want to be in there for a long journey. No contest as far as I am concerned, the QP every time, you could happily go across Europe as a rear passenger..You definitely need to try the Rapide if that's a consideration, to see if you feel the same. They haven't sold well and I think that's one reason.
 

Bourekoue

Junior Member
Messages
297
The QP is a 4 door practical 4 seater; the Rapide is a 2+2. I was very surprised by the back seats of the Rapide when I tried it - very claustrophobic, tiny windows, no room at all either side, no decent leg room. I had great difficulty getting in and out the back easily (and I'm only average height); if you or your family are tall you'd really not want to be in there for a long journey. No contest as far as I am concerned, the QP every time, you could happily go across Europe as a rear passenger..You definitely need to try the Rapide if that's a consideration, to see if you feel the same. They haven't sold well and I think that's one reason.

Yes I believe you are quite correct about the rapide and it's drawbacks.
I recently had my first child and plan on more so size of the children is irrelevant for now but if I have a 3rd child the rapide will become useless so I'm leaning heavily in favour of the QP GT S. Harry metcalfe of evo reviewed the rapide and said his granturismo had much more rear room albeit with two less doors.
As I've said before one of the great attractions of the QP GT S to me is it's practicality coupled with its unique style and character.
Can anybody think of another saloon (past and present) with this much style and fun to be had driving it ?
 

BJL

Member
Messages
1,364
With 6 month old Ghiblis trading at well below 40k it could be the smart move to go for the limited available GTS
 

Andyk

Member
Messages
61,353
With 6 month old Ghiblis trading at well below 40k it could be the smart move to go for the limited available GTS

As you are keeping th e car for aome time the GTS must be the way to go...This is regarding as the best of the QP's and should show in its price over time...The GHibli is more mainstream and should be a bigger seller hitting resale value.....
 

Rwc13

Member
Messages
1,668
With 6 month old Ghiblis trading at well below 40k it could be the smart move to go for the limited available GTS

Really? Ghibli S or Diesel? This thread is about comparing the Ghibli S with the GTS. Where is the evidence that a 6 month old Ghibli S is trading below £40k? As an owner, I have very recent evidence that utterly contradicts that
 

Andyk

Member
Messages
61,353

Rwc13

Member
Messages
1,668
Yes, but my point is when trying to help inform the OPs choice between a GTS and a Ghibli S, it is ridiculous and completely unhelpful to be quoting trade figures for a Ghibli D. Of course a base Ghibli D that sold at £50k is going to trade at £40k after 6 months. You get there by just taking the VAT off.
 

Andyk

Member
Messages
61,353
Yes I agree....If you are thinking of a QP GTS then a GHibli Diesel wouldn't be on your list as they are very different cars...The only one would be the S and 20k more...
 

Bourekoue

Junior Member
Messages
297
If I was in the market for a diesel then maybe but a Maserati diesel just doesn't sit right with me.
 

Bourekoue

Junior Member
Messages
297

Because with all due respect to diesel drivers I'm not looking for an everyday car and I am not concerned at all about fuel consumption. I want a car that feels special every time I get in it.
What would everyone choose between a rapide and a QP Sport GT S or is there another high powered 4 door saloon alternative that you guys prefer ?
 

bigbob

Member
Messages
8,973
We are going completely off piste here. The OP wants a lifer so residuals are irrelevant and I can't imagine him wanting a diesel.

If I was you I would drive a Ghibli S and a 4.7 QP then buy one. Easy!
 

Fangio63

Member
Messages
614
For me it would be the QP..... finding a good one in the right spec and colour will be a challenge though..

But if you go the Ghibli route then drive a very hard bargain...

I've never heard of anyone ever paying list price - or even ticket price for a new / nearly new Maserati... all dealers in my experience are prepared to offer decent discounts....

The cars are made to order - and dealers order in stock cars, quite a few of which are sold as "used cars" a few months later.... As dealers register these - they are particularly vulnerable to a deal at the time the number plates trip over to the next year..

Though its some time ago now when I bought my 4200 cambia corsa from Maranello they had a number of stock cars - which they only discussed after I'd told them i was off to Graypaul to buy one of theirs.. I ended up with a choice of 6 vehicles in various colours and bought one ... had I specced it up and paid list + options the price of the car would have been £72,500.... I paid £48,000 for it.... with just 81 miles on the clock... and 2 weeks before the 03 plate tripped over to 04...

Very recently done much the same thing with an Alfa Mito... "used car" with just 10 miles on it.. registered 6 months ago.. £17k list... £12,900 paid..

There are enough Ghibli S cars swilling around the dealer network for you to get precisely the colour / spec you want... and I dare say the rest is like the essence of great comedy ..... timing... When these guys need to hit a quarter end target or plates change - there are deals to be done..

Ridgeway at Oxford have just set up a new dealership (not formally opened yet) ... but Steve there seems highly motivated to move some metal... so If I was in the market I'd have a chat with him first... see what he's got out the back still wrapped up but registered and very shortly will look like its a year old ..
 

TridentTested

Member
Messages
1,819
I need a practical 4 door saloon now that I'm a family guy

I hate to raise the boring subject of boot space on a Maser forum but the Ghibli looks a much better bet for day-to-day usefulness as a family wagon; the boot is considerably bigger than the QP V's modest offering, and more importantly the rear seats fold which makes it much more versatile.

I know many own their Maseratis as 2nd, 3rd, or whatever-th cars, I know another QP V owner who recently bought a £1,000 Scenic purely to haul some stuff around, but I only have parking for one car and I do find the QP V's boot restrictive.
 

Bourekoue

Junior Member
Messages
297
We are going completely off piste here. The OP wants a lifer so residuals are irrelevant and I can't imagine him wanting a diesel.

If I was you I would drive a Ghibli S and a 4.7 QP then buy one. Easy!

That's right I do not want to even consider a diesel
 

Bourekoue

Junior Member
Messages
297
I hate to raise the boring subject of boot space on a Maser forum but the Ghibli looks a much better bet for day-to-day usefulness as a family wagon; the boot is considerably bigger than the QP V's modest offering, and more importantly the rear seats fold which makes it much more versatile.

I know many own their Maseratis as 2nd, 3rd, or whatever-th cars, I know another QP V owner who recently bought a £1,000 Scenic purely to haul some stuff around, but I only have parking for one car and I do find the QP V's boot restrictive.
I will have to get the official made to measure maserati luggage then !
 

Bourekoue

Junior Member
Messages
297
Fangio63 I agree that the QP is rare to find in certain colour combinations so that certainly plays a role.
As for the ghibli I'm certain like you that there are huge savings to be had.